Failed tests
Products where a published independent test found far less creatine than the label claims. Results apply to the lot that was tested. Brands may have reformulated since, and we note disputes where we know of them.
| Product | Result | What was found | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Creatine Monohydrate Gummies (90 ct tub) Create |
Mixed results | NOW Foods (in-house HPLC) (2024-03-01): found less than label claim (amount not published); James Smith (commissioned) (2025-07): found 3.25 g vs 4.5 g claimed | source ↗ source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies Ovrload |
Failed | James Smith (commissioned) (2025-07): found borderline undetectable vs 5 g claimed; Known Nutrition (competitor, commissioned) (n.d.): found not detected (Blue Raspberry); 0.756 mg (Sour Watermelon) | source ↗ source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies (Strawberry / Apple) PUSH |
Failed | James Smith (commissioned) (2025-07): found 0.102 g (strawberry), 0.112 g (apple) vs 5 g claimed | source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies Gains Nutrition |
Failed | James Smith (commissioned) (2025-07): found borderline undetectable (<=0.11 g/serving per NutraIngredients) | source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies Unique Physique |
Failed | James Smith (commissioned) (2025-07): found borderline undetectable (<=0.11 g/serving per NutraIngredients) | source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies Supplmnt |
Failed | James Smith (commissioned) (2025-07): found borderline undetectable (<=0.11 g/serving per NutraIngredients) | source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies (Amazon) Happyummmm |
Failed | SuppCo (2025-06-12): found 0.005 g vs 5 g claimed | source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies (Amazon) DivinusLabs |
Failed | SuppCo (2025-06-12): found 0.025 g vs 5 g claimed | source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies (Amazon) EcoWise |
Failed | SuppCo (2025-06-12): found 0 g (not detected) vs 5 g claimed | source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies (Amazon) Vidabotan |
Failed | SuppCo (2025-06-12): found 0 g (not detected) vs 5 g claimed | source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies Astro Labs |
Failed | NOW Foods (in-house HPLC) (2024-03-01): found less than label claim (amount not published) | source ↗ |
| Creatine Infused Gummies (75 ct tub) Beast Bites |
Failed | NOW Foods (in-house HPLC) (2024-03-01): found less than label claim (amount not published) | source ↗ |
| Creatine HCl Gummies CON-CRĒT |
Failed | NOW Foods (in-house HPLC) (2024-03-01): found less than label claim (amount not published) | source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies Greabby |
Failed | NOW Foods (in-house HPLC) (2024-03-01): found less than label claim (amount not published) | source ↗ |
| Creatine Gummies Njord |
Failed | NOW Foods (in-house HPLC) (2024-03-01): found less than label claim (amount not published) | source ↗ |
14 failed, 1 mixed. Every row links to the original report.